The collective shrug: embracing reasonableness over rigidity
Written by Common Approach staff
🤷♂️ What is the collective shrug?
The “collective shrug” is a metaphor used in the Common Framework to signal a shift in mindset about impact data aggregation. It means accepting that we may never get perfectly uniform or precise data across a diverse ecosystem—and that’s okay.
Instead of striving for an impossible level of accuracy or uniformity, we aim for reasonableness and transparency over rigid uniformity.
In practical terms, the collective shrug acknowledges that:
• Aggregated indicators won’t be exact, but they can still be useful. Different organizations may define or measure the same concept differently, but if they’re close enough and transparently grouped, they can be aggregated.
• It’s better to interpret diverse data carefully than to ignore it or impose a one-size-fits-all metric.
Looking for a real-world application? Watch an example of concept-based aggregation from a Common Framework user
Why is this mindset important?
Without the collective shrug, efforts to aggregate impact data often fall into two traps:
• Forcing uniform indicators which can alienate or burden social purpose organizations.
• Avoiding aggregation completely, leaving decision-makers with no insight.
So instead, we “shrug”—collectively—and agree: “Let’s not pretend this is perfect, but let’s do it transparently, reasonably, and usefully.”
Looking to learn more about embracing flexibility over uniformity? Read our blog “Creating Flexible Standards: Construct-Based Equivalence”
More like this
Tamarack letter: our response
Common Approach to Impact Measurement is proud to stand with the sector in signing the Tamarack Institute’s “Open Letter from Canada’s Nonprofits and Charities to Corporate and Philanthropic Funders.” As it states, “the time is now to advance trust-based community investment, not slide backwards.”
Steps for reviewing your ETL pipeline
Discussing the ETL pipeline, an often unaddressed step in the impact measurement process, and how reviewing and refining this pipeline can address many common hurdles & lead to efficient and reliable data.
Reflections and readiness: evolving our approach for the Social Finance Fund
Common Approach is continuing our work supporting the impact measurement approach of the Government of Canada’s Social Finance Fund. As we continue with this work, we want to share reflections on what we’ve learned and how we’re adjusting our strategy to better support the field.
